Is Etsy the Best Place to Sell in 2023? Reviews and Alternatives

Are you wondering if Etsy is the best place to sell your products on your ecommerce store? In today’s ever-changing market, understanding the current trends and evaluating the potential benefits and drawbacks of selling on Etsy is crucial for ecommerce stores, online shoppers, and handmade businesses.

Table of Contents

As an ecommerce platform, Etsy offers a platform for small business craft shops to showcase their talents and connect with a global audience. Known for its handmade and unique items, Etsy is the go-to marketplace for creative entrepreneurs.

But is it worth investing your time and effort into selling on Etsy, the popular online marketplace for craft and handmade businesses, in 2023?

Online shoppers are increasingly turning to ecommerce platforms like Etsy to support small businesses and find unique, one-of-a-kind items. That’s the burning question we’ll explore together. By analyzing the growth and competition within the ecommerce marketplace, specifically in the handmade business and craft industry, we’ll delve into what sets the Etsy platform apart from other online shops.

Whether you’re a success planner or just starting out in the craft ecommerce industry, understanding the factors that impact your profit on Etsy can help you make informed decisions about your business and attract online shoppers.

So, let’s dive deeper into the world of Etsy, the ultimate platform for craft and handmade businesses in the ecommerce industry, and uncover whether it truly holds the key to unlocking your entrepreneurial dreams. Are you ready to explore this exciting journey?

Frase is the all-in-one AI Content tool that helps SEO and Content Teams research, write, and optimize better SEO content, faster. Give it a try today!


Pros and Cons of Having an Etsy Shop

Advantages of Reaching a Large Customer Base

One major advantage of having an Etsy shop is the potential to reach a large customer base, especially for ecommerce and online shoppers. This can greatly benefit your handmade business by generating many sales. With millions of online shoppers on the Etsy ecommerce platform, it provides a ready-made audience for your handmade business and craft products.

This can significantly increase your chances of making sales and gaining exposure for your handmade business product, ultimately leading to higher profit.

Additionally, it is important to pay attention to the quality of your product to ensure customer satisfaction.

  • Increased visibility for your handmade business: By selling your handmade products on Etsy, you can tap into its established reputation and benefit from its high traffic, attracting more shoppers and increasing your profit. This means that more potential customers will come across your handmade business products on Etsy shops, increasing your profit, compared to if you were starting from scratch on your own website. Additionally, using Etsy’s shipping options can make the process more convenient for both you and your customers.
  • Targeted audience: Etsy attracts people who are seeking unique, handmade, vintage items to sell on their business. If your handmade business products align with the preferences of Etsy shoppers, you have a higher chance of attracting interested buyers who are actively searching for what you offer. This can ultimately lead to increased profit for Etsy sellers.
  • Etsy’s global presence is a great advantage for your handmade business. It allows you to ship your products to shoppers worldwide, expanding your international reach without the need for extensive marketing efforts. This opens up opportunities for your handmade business to expand its customer base beyond local or regional boundaries by offering your product for shipping. People from all over can now purchase your product and support your business.

Limitations of Relying Solely on Etsy

While there are advantages to selling your handmade products on Etsy, it’s important for handmade business owners to consider the limitations as well, especially when it comes to attracting shoppers and managing shipping.

  • Limited brand control: When operating solely through an Etsy shop, you have limited control over branding elements such as the overall look and feel of your product, business, and sell to shoppers. Your Etsy shop may blend in with other sellers’ listings, making it challenging for shoppers to differentiate your product and establish a distinct business identity.
  • With millions of shoppers looking for products on Etsy, competition among businesses can be fierce. Sellers are vying for attention and trying to attract customers to save money. It may require additional effort for shoppers to find and choose your business among the many Etsy shops. Optimizing product listings, enhancing product photography, and implementing effective marketing strategies are key to standing out from the crowd and selling successfully.
  • Dependence on third-party platforms: Relying solely on Etsy to sell your products means that your business’s success and ability to make money are tied directly to its policies and algorithms, which may affect how shoppers discover your products. Changes in these factors, such as product selection and pricing, could impact your visibility to shoppers or even lead to account suspension, potentially disrupting your sales and business operations on Etsy shops. It’s important to carefully consider these factors to ensure you are maximizing your chances of making money on the platform.

Evaluating the Ease of Setting Up and Managing an Etsy Shop

Setting up and managing an Etsy shop is a crucial step for any business looking to attract shoppers and make money.

It’s important to consider the unique aspects of running an Etsy shop to ensure success in the online marketplace.

  • User-friendly interface: Etsy provides a relatively easy-to-use platform for shoppers to set up their businesses and save money. Creating a seller account on Etsy is worth it for businesses looking to make money. Shoppers can find your product listings and shop’s appearance customized to attract more customers. This simplicity makes it accessible even for Etsy shoppers with limited technical expertise, helping them save money and grow their businesses.
  • Built-in features: Etsy offers various built-in features to help business sellers manage their shops effectively and make money. These shop tools, available on Etsy, include inventory tracking, order management tools, and customer communication options. They are essential for any business looking to make money. These features can streamline the selling process for your business, enhance overall efficiency, and help you make more money on Etsy.
  • Time commitment in managing a business: While setting up an Etsy shop for your business is relatively straightforward, managing it requires ongoing time and effort. This includes tasks such as responding to customer inquiries, processing orders in the shop, updating product listings on Etsy, and staying on top of marketing efforts for the business.

Assessing Fees and Costs Associated with Running an Etsy Shop

Running an Etsy business shop comes with certain business fees and costs that need to be considered for your business.

  • Listing fees: Each item listed in your Etsy shop incurs a small fee for your business. While this may seem insignificant for individual listings, it can add up if you have a large inventory or frequently update your products in your Etsy shop. This can greatly impact the worth of your business on Etsy.
  • Transaction fees: When you make a sale in your Etsy shop, they charge a transaction fee based on the total sale price of your business. This fee covers payment processing for your Etsy shop, as well as access to various seller tools. It is essential for your business and determining your Etsy worth.

Comparing an Online Store to Selling on Etsy in 2023

In the ever-evolving world of online shopping, business owners and creatives have multiple options to showcase and sell their products. One popular platform for selling handmade and unique items is Etsy. If you’re wondering about the worth of your Etsy business, there are various factors to consider.

One popular choice for starting a business is setting up an online shop, while another option is selling on established platforms like Etsy. Let’s explore the key differences between selling on Etsy and running your own online shop business, and determine whether Etsy is the best place to sell your products in 2023.

More Control over Branding and Customization Options

Having your own online shop provides you with greater control over branding and customization options for your business. With platforms like Etsy, you can create a unique store that showcases your products and highlights what makes your business worth checking out.

With Etsy, you can design a storefront that perfectly aligns with your business brand image, choose your own domain name, and create a unique shopping experience for your customers. With complete creative freedom, you can tailor every aspect of your online shop to reflect your vision. Etsy is worth exploring for your online business.

On the other hand, when running a business and selling products on an Etsy shop, you are limited to the platform’s predefined templates and layouts. While you can personalize certain elements such as shop banners and product descriptions, the overall look and feel of your business will still be within the confines of Etsy’s design framework.

Level of Exposure: Online Store vs. Selling on Etsy

Both options offer distinct advantages. An Etsy business online store allows you to tap into various marketing channels such as social media, email campaigns, influencer collaborations, and search engine optimization (SEO). By effectively leveraging these strategies for your business on Etsy, you can drive traffic directly to your Etsy shop and increase visibility among potential customers.

On the other hand, selling on a popular business marketplace like Etsy gives you access to a vast customer base already familiar with the platform. With millions of active shoppers browsing through Etsy daily in search of unique business products or vintage business finds, you benefit from immediate exposure without having to build a business audience from scratch.

Customer Trust Levels: Independent Online Store vs. Trusted Platform

Trust plays a crucial role in e-commerce transactions. When customers purchase from an independent online store on Etsy, a popular platform for small business owners, that they may not be familiar with, they may have reservations about the credibility and security of their personal information. Establishing a trust can take time and effort, especially for new businesses on Etsy.

In contrast, Etsy has already established itself as a trusted business platform among online shoppers. Etsy, a popular online business platform, has established itself as a trusted source for secure shopping experiences and customer protection.

With its policies and buyer protection programs, Etsy ensures customer interests are safeguarded throughout the purchasing process. As a result, customers often feel more confident making purchases on Etsy compared to independent online business stores.

Technical Skills Required: Setting Up an Online Store vs. Using Etsy’s Interface

Setting up and maintaining an online store on Etsy requires some technical skills for your business. When starting an Etsy business, you need to choose the right e-commerce platform, set up reliable hosting, effectively manage inventory, securely process payments, and handle essential website maintenance tasks such as updates and backups. While these Etsy business skills can be learned or outsourced, they do require additional time and resources.

On the other hand, using Etsy’s user-friendly interface is perfect for small business owners who have minimal technical expertise. The Etsy platform provides intuitive tools for listing products and managing orders, making it easy for businesses to communicate with customers and handle payments. All of this is done within a streamlined interface designed to simplify the selling process.

Understanding the Impact of Customer Ownership Concerns on Etsy

Etsy has established itself as a popular marketplace. However, some potential customers may have concerns regarding customer ownership when purchasing from individual sellers on Etsy, a popular platform for small business owners.

Addressing Intellectual Property Rights Concerns

One common concern among business customers is the protection of intellectual property rights when purchasing handmade products on Etsy. Etsy business customers want reassurance that the items they buy on Etsy are original and not infringing upon any copyrights or trademarks.

Etsy sellers must take steps to address concerns related to their business by providing clear information about the authenticity of their products and ensuring compliance with intellectual property laws.

  • Pros:
    • By addressing intellectual property rights concerns on Etsy, sellers can build trust with their customers.
    • Providing proof of authenticity, such as certificates of origin or detailed descriptions, can alleviate ownership worries when purchasing items on Etsy.
  • Cons:
    • Failure to address these concerns on Etsy may result in lost sales opportunities.
    • Negative Etsy reviews related to intellectual property issues can significantly harm a seller’s reputation.

The Influence of Buyer Reviews on Consumer Confidence

Buyer reviews play a significant role in influencing consumer confidence when making purchases on Etsy. Customers often rely on the experiences shared by previous buyers on Etsy to gauge the quality and reliability of individual sellers.

Positive reviews on Etsy can boost consumer trust and encourage potential buyers to make a purchase on the platform. Conversely, negative reviews can deter customers from engaging with certain Etsy sellers.

  • Pros:
    • Positive buyer reviews on Etsy contribute to increased sales and repeat business on the platform.
    • Encouraging satisfied customers to leave feedback on Etsy can greatly enhance a seller’s reputation.
  • Cons:
    • Negative buyer reviews on Etsy can result in decreased sales and a loss of potential customers.
    • The lack of buyer feedback on Etsy can raise doubts about a seller’s credibility.

The Impact of Customer Ownership Concerns on Seller Reputation

Customer ownership concerns directly affect a seller’s reputation within the Etsy marketplace. Etsy sellers who consistently address concerns related to their products and provide exceptional customer service on the Etsy platform are more likely to establish a positive reputation among buyers.

On the other hand, Etsy sellers who fail to mitigate ownership worries may face negative feedback and a decline in their overall sales performance on Etsy.

  • Pros:
    • Addressing customer ownership concerns on Etsy can lead to positive reviews and increased sales on the platform.
    • Building a strong reputation as a trustworthy Etsy seller can attract repeat business.
  • Cons:
    • Ignoring or mishandling customer ownership concerns on Etsy may result in poor reviews and damage to a seller’s reputation.
    • A negative reputation on Etsy can deter potential customers from making purchases on the platform.

Mitigating Ownership Concerns on Etsy

Both customers and sellers have measures they can take to mitigate ownership concerns within the context of selling on Etsy. Customers shopping on Etsy should thoroughly review product descriptions, ask questions about authenticity, and research sellers’ reputations before making a purchase on the platform.

Meanwhile, Etsy sellers should prioritize clear communication on the platform, provide accurate product details for their Etsy listings, offer return policies to customers, and promptly address any customer issues that arise while selling on Etsy.

Exploring Alternatives to Etsy for Selling Handmade Products

If you’re a creative entrepreneur looking to sell your handmade products, you may have considered setting up a shop on Etsy. While Etsy is undoubtedly a popular online marketplace for artisans and crafters, it’s not the only platform available.

ArtFire and Zibbet: Tailored Marketplaces for Handmade Goods

Platforms like ArtFire and Zibbet offer alternatives to Etsy. These marketplaces, such as Etsy, cater specifically to artisans and crafters, providing them with a dedicated space on Etsy to showcase their creations.

Both ArtFire and Zibbet offer features similar to those found on Etsy, such as customizable shops, product listings, and payment processing.


  • Specialized platforms focused solely on handmade goods.
  • Less competition compared to larger marketplaces like Etsy.
  • A dedicated community of buyers interested in supporting independent artists.


  • Smaller user base compared to Etsy.
  • Limited brand recognition compared to more established platforms.
  • May require additional marketing efforts on Etsy to drive traffic and sales.

Leveraging Social Media Platforms for Promotion and Sales

In addition to specialized marketplaces like Etsy, social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook can be powerful tools for promoting and selling your handmade products. These platforms, such as Etsy, provide an opportunity to connect directly with potential customers through visually appealing content.


  • With billions of active users on both Instagram and Facebook, Etsy has a wide reach.
  • Ability to target specific audiences on Etsy based on interests or demographics.
  • Etsy offers a cost-effective way of promoting your products through organic posts or targeted ads on the platform.


  • Limited e-commerce functionality within the platforms themselves.
  • Building a following and engaging with followers on Etsy requires consistent effort.
  • Competition from other Etsy businesses vying for attention in users’ feeds is increasing.

Setting Up an Independent E-commerce Website

For those looking for complete control over their online presence, setting up an independent e-commerce website on platforms like Etsy can be an appealing option. This allows you to create a unique brand identity and customize the shopping experience for your customers on Etsy.


  • Full control over branding, design, and customer experience.
  • Ability to build a loyal customer base directly on your Etsy shop.
  • No platform fees or restrictions are imposed by third-party marketplaces like Etsy.


  • Setting up and maintaining a website on Etsy requires technical knowledge or assistance.
  • Higher upfront costs for domain registration, hosting, web development, and Etsy.
  • May require additional marketing efforts to drive traffic to your Etsy shop.

Comparing Reach and Target Audience

When considering alternatives to Etsy, it’s important to evaluate the potential reach and target audience of each platform. While Etsy boasts a large user base with millions of shoppers actively searching for handmade goods, smaller platforms like ArtFire or Zibbet may offer a more niche audience interested specifically in supporting independent artists.

Ultimately, Etsy is the best place to sell your handmade products. It will depend on your specific goals and preferences as a seller. Whether you choose to explore specialized marketplaces like ArtFire or Zibbet, leverage social media platforms for promotion and sales, or set up an independent e-commerce website – there are alternative options available outside of Etsy that can help you showcase your creativity and reach potential customers who appreciate the value of handmade goods.

The Effectiveness of Marketing Strategies on Etsy

To maximize your success as a seller on Etsy, it’s crucial to implement effective marketing strategies. Let’s delve into the impact of various techniques and approaches that can boost your visibility, drive traffic, and increase sales within the Etsy marketplace.

Utilizing Keywords, Tags, and SEO Techniques

One key aspect of promoting your products on Etsy is optimizing your listings with relevant keywords, tags, and search engine optimization (SEO) techniques.

By strategically incorporating popular search terms like “Etsy” that potential customers may use when looking for products on platforms like Etsy, you can improve your chances of appearing in their search results.

  • Pros:
    • Increased visibility and discoverability.
    • Higher likelihood of attracting interested buyers.
    • Improved ranking in search results.
  • Cons:
    • Competition from other sellers targeting similar keywords.
    • Constant need to stay updated with trending keywords.

Social Media Marketing for Driving Traffic and Sales

In today’s digital landscape, leveraging social media platforms is an effective way to reach a wider audience beyond just Etsy shoppers.

By creating engaging content, showcasing your products, and directing followers to your Etsy store, you can generate more traffic and potentially increase sales.

  • Pros:
    • Expanded reach beyond the Etsy community.
    • Opportunities for direct interaction with potential customers.
    • Ability to build brand awareness and loyalty.
  • Cons:
    • Time-consuming nature of managing multiple social media accounts.
    • Need for consistent content creation and engagement.

The Power of Customer Reviews and Word-of-Mouth Marketing

Customer reviews play a significant role in establishing trust within the Etsy community. Positive reviews on Etsy not only attract new customers but also enhance your Etsy shop’s reputation.

Word-of-mouth marketing on platforms like Etsy further amplifies the effect of satisfied customers recommending your Etsy products to others.

  • Pros:
    • Increased credibility through positive customer testimonials.
    • Given the potential for organic growth on Etsy, satisfied customers can easily spread the word about their positive experience.
    • Positive impact on sales and customer loyalty.
  • Cons:
    • The possibility of negative reviews impacting your reputation.
    • Need for consistent customer satisfaction to maintain positive feedback.

Successful Marketing Strategies Employed by Top-performing Sellers

To excel on Etsy, it’s essential to learn from successful sellers who have already established themselves within the marketplace.

Studying Etsy’s marketing strategies can provide valuable insights and inspiration for your own business growth.

  • Key Strategies:
    • Building an email list for targeted marketing campaigns.
    • Utilizing multichannel selling to expand your market reach.
    • Collaborating with influencers or bloggers to promote your products.

By adopting these proven strategies, you can take advantage of the opportunities Etsy offers and maximize your chances of success in this competitive marketplace.

Analyzing the Profitability of Selling Art on Etsy

Pricing Strategies for Maximizing Profitability

One of the key factors that artists on Etsy need to consider is their pricing strategy. It’s important to find a balance between maximizing profitability and remaining competitive on Etsy, the online marketplace. Artists should take into account not only the cost of materials and production time but also consider factors like shipping costs and fees associated with selling on Etsy.

To maximize profitability, artists can employ different pricing strategies. Some may choose to set higher prices on Etsy to reflect the value of their art and cover all expenses, while others may opt for lower prices on Etsy to attract more buyers.

It’s crucial for artists to conduct a thorough research by analyzing similar products on Etsy and understanding their price range.


  • Higher prices can lead to increased profit margins.
  • Lower prices on Etsy can attract more customers and generate higher sales volume.


  • Higher prices may deter some potential buyers.
  • Lower prices may result in lower profit margins.

Market Demand for Different Art Products

Understanding market demand is essential for artists looking to sell their art on Etsy successfully. By analyzing what types of art products are popular among Etsy users, artists can tailor their creations accordingly and increase their chances of making sales. Conducting thorough research within the Etsy marketplace will provide valuable insights into which art forms or styles are currently trending.

Artists on Etsy can also leverage customer reviews and feedback as a source of information about market demand. By paying attention to what customers are saying about similar products on Etsy, artists can identify patterns or preferences that could guide their own artistic choices.

Key Information:

  • Research popular art forms/styles on Etsy.
  • Pay attention to customer reviews and feedback.

Impact of Shipping Costs, Production Time, and Material Expenses

When calculating profitability on Etsy, it’s crucial for artists to factor in various costs that affect their bottom line. Shipping costs on Etsy are crucial in determining overall profitability, as they can vary based on the size, weight, and destination of the art piece. Etsy artists should carefully consider how to price their products on the Etsy platform to cover these expenses without deterring potential buyers.

Production time and material expenses are important factors to consider when selling on Etsy. Artists on Etsy need to assess how much time they spend creating each piece and factor in the cost of materials used.

By understanding the costs associated with selling on platforms like Etsy, artists can set prices that not only cover their expenses but also ensure a reasonable profit margin.

Key Information:

  • Consider shipping costs when pricing art products.
  • Factor in production time and material expenses.

Success Stories and Challenges Faced by Etsy Artists

To gain insights into the profitability of selling art on Etsy, it’s valuable to look at success stories from artists who have achieved consistent income through the platform. These stories can provide inspiration and guidance for other artists looking to establish themselves on Etsy.

However, it’s important to acknowledge that challenges exist on Etsy as well. Some artists may struggle with generating consistent sales or face difficulties in navigating fees and account details on Etsy. Understanding both success stories and challenges on Etsy can help artists develop strategies to overcome obstacles and increase their chances of profitability on the platform.


  • Success stories: Etsy artists who have built a loyal customer base or received recognition for their work.
  • Challenges on Etsy can arise from difficulty in standing out among competitors or managing fees effectively.

Is Etsy the Best Place to Sell?

Now that we’ve explored the pros and cons of having an Etsy shop, compared it to selling on your own online store, delved into customer ownership concerns, explored alternatives, analyzed marketing strategies, and examined the profitability of selling art on Etsy, you might be wondering: is Etsy really the best place to sell? Well, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. It ultimately depends on your unique goals and circumstances.

Etsy offers a vibrant marketplace with a built-in audience of millions of buyers actively seeking handmade products. Etsy provides a user-friendly platform for sellers to showcase their products. It takes care of many aspects like payment processing and customer support, making it easier for sellers to manage their online shops on Etsy.

However, it also comes with Etsy fees and limitations that may not suit everyone’s needs. If you’re looking for convenience and exposure to a targeted audience, Etsy can be a fantastic option. But if you crave more control over your brand and want to avoid certain restrictions or expenses, exploring alternatives like Etsy might be worth considering.

In conclusion, take some time to reflect on what matters most to you as an Etsy seller. Consider your long-term goals, budget constraints, branding preferences, desired level of independence, and the potential of selling on Etsy. Don’t rush into any decisions—weigh the pros and cons carefully before choosing whether Etsy is truly the best place for you to sell.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I have my own website while also selling on Etsy?

Yes! Many sellers choose to have their own website alongside an Etsy shop. Having your own Etsy website allows you to build your brand independently and gives you full control over design elements and customer experience. You can use Etsy as a complementary platform where you can showcase additional products or offer exclusive deals.

Are there any other platforms similar to Etsy?

Yes! There are several alternative platforms, like Etsy, where you can sell handmade products online. Some popular options include Shopify (which allows you to create your own online store), Amazon Handmade (with its vast customer base), eBay (known for its auction-style listings), Etsy (a platform for selling handmade and vintage items), and even social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook Marketplace.

How can I increase my sales on Etsy?

To boost your sales on Etsy, consider optimizing your product listings with high-quality images and detailed descriptions. Utilize keywords relevant to your Etsy products in titles and tags to improve search visibility on Etsy. Offer excellent customer service on Etsy, respond promptly to inquiries about Etsy products, and encourage positive reviews on Etsy. Promote your Etsy shop through social media channels, collaborations with Etsy influencers or bloggers, and participating in relevant online Etsy communities.

Can I sell digital products on Etsy?

Yes! In addition to physical handmade items, Etsy allows sellers to offer digital downloads such as printables, patterns, templates, or digital art. Selling digital products on Etsy can be a great way to expand your offerings and reach a wider audience without the need for physical inventory or shipping.

How much does it cost to sell on Etsy?

Etsy charges several fees for selling on their platform. These include listing fees (for each item you list), transaction fees (a percentage of the sale price), payment processing fees (if you use Etsy’s payment system), and optional advertising fees if you choose to promote your listings. It’s essential to factor in these costs when pricing your items and determining profitability.